Vox Analytica Files : A Data Driven Look at Permanent Establishment

On June 6, 2018, the Authority for Advanced Rulings pronounced its decision in the case of MasterCard Asia Pte. Ltd. on the issue of whether there was a permanent establishment of the company in India or not. In a detailed judgment, the Authority ruled as follows: The setting up of Indian operations of MasterCard has … Continue reading Vox Analytica Files : A Data Driven Look at Permanent Establishment

Per Incuriam Cases – II

A judgment of the court is not a binding precedent if given per incuriam, i.e., it is either: A judgment that is passed in ignorance of a relevant statutory provision; or A judgment that is passed without considering binding precedent of a coordinate or larger bench. As discussed in the earlier article, the significance of a judgment having … Continue reading Per Incuriam Cases – II

Most Cited Unreported Judgments

Last week in our article series we discussed the oft overlooked unreported judgments. After establishing how these judgments are a prominent part of the corpus of judicial literature in India, and a valuable resource for any diligent practitioner, we thought we’d trawl our database to uncover the most popular unreported judgements. These judgements on important … Continue reading Most Cited Unreported Judgments